Prose vs. Bumble and Bumble: Which Haircare Brand Truly Delivers?

Editor’s Note: Right now, our winner is giving you 50% off your first order! This is a deal that comes around ONCE in a blue moon. Seriously, if you’ve ever even considered Prose, NOW is the time. Once this deal goes, we’re not sure if it’s ever coming back.

When it comes to haircare, I used to think the more luxurious the brand, the better the results. I’ve spent years switching between salon favorites like Bumble and Bumble, always hoping for that magical “just walked out of a blowout” feeling. But then I discovered Prose, a completely personalized haircare line, and my perspective on what defines great haircare changed entirely.

Curious to see how these two brands stack up, I decided to put them to the test. Here’s what I found:

Test #1: Customization

Bumble and Bumble offers an impressive range of products tailored to specific hair types and concerns, like frizz or oiliness. Their hair quiz is helpful for narrowing down options, but you still have to choose which product will address your biggest issue—what if you have more than one?

Prose takes customization to the next level by formulating products that can tackle multiple hair concerns simultaneously. Their hair quiz doesn’t just stop at your hair type; it also factors in your environment (like pollution and humidity) and your unique combination of needs. 

For me, that meant a shampoo and conditioner specifically crafted for my fine, slightly oily hair that also gets frizzy in humid weather. No compromises, no scrolling through endless options—it only took 5 minutes to find the perfect match!

Winner: Prose

Test #2: Adaptability

One of the most impressive features of Prose is its adaptability. Hair needs aren’t static—they change with the seasons, your environment, and even your lifestyle. Whether you move to a new city with a different climate, start coloring your hair, or suddenly notice new concerns like dryness or thinning, Prose has you covered.

Their hair quiz isn’t a one-and-done deal. You can retake it anytime to adjust your formula, ensuring your products always match your hair’s current needs. For someone like me, whose hair tends to react to environmental changes (hello, frizz during humid summers!), this level of flexibility has been a game-changer.

Winner: Prose

Test #3: Salon-Worthy Results

Both brands deliver high-performing products that make your hair feel salon-fresh. I do love Bumble and Bumble’s “Hairdresser’s Invisible Oil!” for its ability to smooth and soften my strands, giving them that polished, post-salon look.

With Prose, though, I achieved the same smoothness and shine, plus an added boost of volume—something I’ve struggled to get with Bumble and Bumble’s products, which can occasionally feel a bit heavy on my fine hair.

It’s a tie!

Test #4: Value (Luxury Haircare Without Breaking the Bank)

Bumble and Bumble, as a salon-favorite brand, is priced on the higher side, with shampoos and conditioners often costing $30 or more per bottle. Prose, while not cheap, is still a personalized formula. My custom shampoo and conditioner set cost around $50. Plus, Prose frequently offers bundles or subscription discounts, making it easier to stick to a high-quality haircare routine.

Winner: Prose

Test #5: Clean/Effective Ingredients

I’m not saying Bumble and Bumble uses bad ingredients. They’re cruelty-free and sulfate-free, which is a solid baseline for a luxury haircare brand. But Prose is also free from parabens, phthalates, and GMOs. You can even request silicone-free or fragrance-free formulas if that matters to you. I used to hate trying new products because they always gave me dandruff, but Prose stuff is perfect for those with sensitive scalps like mine. 

As a fun bonus, Prose even lets you choose your fragrance! From soft florals like “Oasis” to the soothing spa-like “Botanica,” or even a fragrance-free option, your shower feels like a mini escape tailored just for you.

Winner: Prose

Final verdict: Prose comes out on top!

While Bumble and Bumble has been a staple in my haircare routine for years, Prose has completely changed the game for me. The level of personalization, clean ingredients, and thoughtful pricing make it the clear winner. 

I’m seriously shocked it took me this long to try it. After all, my hair is one-of-a-kind…shouldn’t my products be too?